The Cleveland Indians do not have a superstar. There are no Cy Young candidates. There are no MVP candidates. If you’re into traditional stats, the team will finish the year without a guy that hit 25 home runs, without a .300 hitter, without a 90 RBI guy, without a pitcher with 15 wins, without a starter with an ERA under 3.00, without a closer with 35 saves, and without a pitcher with 200 strikeouts.
If you’re into advanced stats, the Indians will have three position players with over three wins above replacement player, which is classified as a “good player”. Players between 2-3 WAR are considered “solid starters”, by Fangraphs’s definition of WAR. One “All-Star” in Jason Kipnis. Zero superstars, which is 5-6 WAR, and clearly no MVP-caliber players, which is 6+ WAR. The Indians have pitcher above three WAR, Justin Masterson. The Indians do have five starters with a fielder independent pitching (FIP) mark that falls between “great” at 3.25 and “above average” at 3.75.
What we’re seeing from the Cleveland Indians in 2013 is truly a team effort. Ten players have hit 10 or more home runs with two others currently sitting on a total of nine. Ten players have driven in more than 40 runs. Eight players have scored 40 or more runs. The Indians entered Friday’s game ranked 14th in batting average, but seventh in on-base percentage, and 10th in slugging percentage.