This year's Haiku Contest was much harder to judge than those in years past: I got a lot more entries, and the quality was pretty darn good. Sure, the occasional reader forgot to count to five or seven, but there's lots of good stuff here.
There were a number of different approaches: the Beard/Chin, the Clutch Hitting, the Grinding, the Trade ... and there were a number of common themes. But ultimately, I chose to evaluate the poems in separate categories. There are a LOT that deserve Honorable Mention, but here are the category winners:
In the Beard/Chin Category, the winners are Jason Laurianti and Justin Truitt:
Jason
So, the Beard is Gone
Fasano's 'Stache Has No Friend
Wedge May Grow His Own
Justin
Blake, we will miss thee
Virile chin cut from granite
Sometimes a fungus
In the Grinder/Fan Reaction Category, the winners are Mike Perry and Michael Barnauskas:
Mike
Casey at the bat
Shapiro's grinding dreamboat
In the tribe no more
Michael
My Mom Hates Casey
Blake's in la-la land Mother
Happy Birthday Mom
And in the Actual Poetry Category, the winners are Paul Anderson and Roger Evans:
Paul
Terror at the plate
Is it delight or sadness?
Panic in your glove
Roger
Blake curls aging ash
Splinters at home plate drifting
In Indians' void
To single out everyone who deserves recognition would dillute the meaning, but here are a few that I especially enjoyed for one reason or another:
Alan Florjancic for his message board reference:
Casey Blake is gone.
Board posting at all time low.
Sledge silently weeps.
Anna and/or Laura Burley for her/their sincere fandom in the face of much vitriol over the years:
Casey I'll miss you
Two thousand miles from Cleveland
I'll still watch you play
Jack Mager for a concise synopsis:
Oh bearded wonder...
A career year helped us get...
Top prospects for you!!!!
Jon Cooper for a career summary:
Casey Blake, Tribe star?
Flourished under Wedge, for sure
Bench jockey elsewhere
And Barry McBride for the minimalist purity:
Blake Blake Blake Blake Blake
Blake Death Blake Blake Blake Blake Blake
Blake Blake Death Death Blake
I liked a lot more of these: please enjoy, and thanks to everyone who entered!
Jason Laurianti
Casey Blake was
A fake in Two Thousand Eight
More Garko Than Ryan
Wedge Told Casey "Bye"
The Two They Shed a Tear While
The Cleveland Fans Cheered!
Cleveland Curse Lives On...
As Casey Goes to Contend
Dodgers Sweep in Four
Career Seasons Bring
On The Changes You Deserve
Good Luck Casey Blake
Casey in the Field:
More Positions Than a One
Night Stand - That's Trade Bait
Casey's Eye Was Keen
His Bat Was Strong in '08
Yet we kept the 'Looch?
Lots of Casey Gear
In the Indian's Team Shop
Sells More Than Del-looch
CC vs. Blake
One is going to be League Champ
Cleveland Curse Lives On
He Cleaned Wedge's Spikes
Neatly Pressed His Uniform
That's the "Go-To" Guy?
The Bases Loaded
And The Ball Goes Through His Legs
That's Casey To Us
Matt Vanderfeen
Casey at the bat
You can't miss what never was
Utility man
Runners not scoring
Starter for the Tribe spelled doom
Underperforming
Blake - always hustles
Fun to watch - like paint drying
But chicks dug the beard
Mike Perry
Sweet soft beard on chin
Whiskers for all Ohio
Now in Dodger Blue
Prospects are desired
Aging veteran with high cost
Silly Dodgers paid
Need a solid glove
With some pop in wooden bat
Dodgers still have needs
Paul Kormerl
Uncertain we'll miss
Mighty Casey at the bat
After a fine trade
The Beard played them all
Except for two positions
With which he's replaced
Worthless with runners,
Now he only hits in clutch,
Trade this anomaly!
David Swader (or David S. Wader)
A gigantic chin
That was not meant to chagrin
Did belong to him
Patrick Fischbach
Driving in runners
You excelled better than most
No more runners home
Charles Buffum
Now at third: Marte.
There is no joy in Cleveland,
Casey has bailed out.
From fourteen out to
only one, Casey Blake scores
while we sink deeper.
The gamer is gone.
So what? So is the season.
Fans get a Wedgie.
Michael Guzak
Good-Bye Mountain Man
Don't Let The Coast Corrupt You
You'll Be Mountin' Men
Justin Truitt
Loved by a few fans
Infuriating at times
Bearded enigma
Marte makes me cry
Blake made him rot on the bench
Come back home Casey
Michael Heinbach
Casey Blake is gone
I'm not sure I care at all
Oye Como Va
Ben Warburton
Your beard will be missed
Delucci can go as well
I love drinking beer
So Luche gets to stay
While CC Walks away
I want to vomit
Wedge loved your hustle
I hated your OPS
Billy Beane conurs
Blake always played hard
did whatever he was told
Wedge equals man crush
Doug Lombardi
Casey Blake for two?
What about Gark and Soo Choo?
No value for slow and blah.
Rich Swerbinsky
The fans wanted more
But you more than enough
Still hate Torre's guts
Nicholas Swerbinsky
That guy must be good:
They let him wear number one!
Blake is not poopy!
Bob Sanok
Good-bye Casey Blake.
We got some prospects for you.
See you back next year!
Chris Koch
casey blake was here.
he played everyday. why?
utility man.
Brian Palicia
Thrived at the hot corner
Matured when he was at bat
It was a fine beard
Mickey Ferguson
What is all the fuss?
Casey Blake was adequate
Brought us fine prospects
Casey Blake's best move
Was leaving the Indians
Prospects good; Blake? Eh.
Michael Kraft
Guaranteed homerun
When there are no ducks on pond
RISP a dirty word
Dave Derrenburger
casey blake is gone
we got carlos santana
guitar hero, not
good-bye casey blake
wedge wants all those pictures back
how else to explain???
favorite grinder
wedge will miss the bearded one
i say good riddance
versatility???
so what??? give me more talent
grinders are losers
casey a dodger
jay leno wants his chin back
beware of razor
Julia Simon
Blake's doing it all
For freakin Torre, not us
Thanks shap - here's hoping
Barry McBride
They called me Death
I was not their final end
Call the basement home
The kind of player
Mike Hargrove would really love
But the Tribe is done
Mediocre player
Perfect for Dolan's ballclub
But now is too old
Exciting? Not much
Stable and steady and dull
California bound
Uncredited Appearance
Casey Blake sucks!
Does he suck? Why yes, he does!
Blake sucks! Wedge's fault.
Farewell, Casey Blake
Number One in our programs
But not in our hearts
Paul Richardson
Chuck Norris Sibling
Ride your beard to victory
There in Anaheim
Indians season
Deal or No Deal is on now
What's the difference?
Mary St. Cyr
Men on the bases
Casey comes up to the plate
Pitcher starts to smile
Erik Mosley
Strike looking, ball, ball
Strike looking, ball, swinging strike
Casey at the bat