In the parthenon that is great
quotes in Cleveland Browns history, most people will recall, “there’s
a gleam, men” from Mary Schottenheimer and “mad dog in a meat market”
from Schottenheimer, again, in describing Mike Junkin, an oft-injured
linebacker from Duke who lasted exactly three years in the NFL.
To those we can now add what hopefully won’t be just as ignominious:
“not a single misspelling in his presentation. It was really
organized.” That was Browns GM Phil Savage explaining some of
the rationale behind the hiring of new offensive coordinator Rob Chudzinksi.
Who knew that the ability to use spell check was so high on the list
of requirements?
The hiring of Chudzinski has
garnered a fair amount of negative publicity among Cleveland’s main
stream media, mainly because of Chudzinksi’s inexperience. For
example, both Bud Shaw and Tony Grossi at the Plain Dealer, in amazingly
similar columns (here and here), noted that Chudzinksi’s hiring
continues the “on-the-job training mentality in Berea.”
Grossi and Shaw may be technically
right but to that we’d ask, what were the alternatives? If Shaw
had his way, the Browns would have hired long-time assistant (and failed
former head coach) Dan Henning for the job. Grossi didn’t say
but we got the distinct impression that if he were in charge, Lindy
Infante would no longer be retired. If the Browns had gone with
another re-tread (like Crennel) that would have received its own share
of criticism that the Browns aren’t nearly as innovative as, say,
the Jets or the Saints or, God forbid, the Steelers, all of whom turned
over their entire franchises to young, relatively inexperienced assistants.
Actually, the hiring of Chudzinski
isn’t so much innovative as it is the continuation of a trend that
Savage started with last year’s free agent signings: brining in folks
who truly understand what the Cleveland Browns mean to this community.
Chudzinksi was reared in Toledo (a highly partisan Browns town, despite
its proximity to Detroit) and is a former Browns coach. Our guess
is that in addition to his spelling skills, what sealed the deal for
Savage was the fact that Chudzinski actually wanted to be here, as opposed
to simply enhancing his resume by taking the almost certain promotion
he would have gotten under the aforementioned Schottenheimer in San
Diego.
What we like most about Chudzinski
is his age. He strikes us as the kind of up and coming coach,
a head coach in the making in fact, which the Browns have been reluctant
to hire in the past. Almost no one gives head coach Romeo Crennel much
of a chance in the long term. He may survive next year but his
coaching days are numbered either way. We like the fact that Savage
is trying to round out the staff with young coaches that have the energy,
fire and drive to be head coaches in the NFL. If/when the Browns
finally cut ties with Crennel it will be far less disruptive if the
job goes to a talented assistant already on staff and not another lifelong
assistant.
In this regard, Chudzinski
fits nicely into the mode of Todd Grantham, the Browns defensive coordinator,
a young, energetic coach with a strong personality who seems to be moving
his charges in the right direction. The Browns defense last year
was pitiful, but this was due mostly to injuries and talent deficit.
At least they looked like they knew what they were supposed to be doing
on most every play, even if they couldn’t fully execute the commands.
The only trepidation we have
whatsoever with Chudzinski is the same trepidation we’d have with
whoever would have been hired: the task is so daunting it could very
well swallow even the most veteran of coaches. The consensus seems
to be that the Browns have some talent on offense, mainly in the form
of Kellen Winslow, Jr. and Braylon Edwards. But it’s so hard
to judge because there is so little talent on this team in the first
place even average players have the chance to stand out as the next
great thing.
Winslow likely will be fine,
particularly under Chudzinski who knows him well. As for Edwards, he’s
a much bigger mystery. Whether fair or not, Chudzinski’s effectiveness
next year will be measured, in part, on his ability to reach Edwards
and turn a budding malcontent me-first Terrell Owens wannabe into a
team-oriented top-tier receiver.
But in actuality, we need not
wait until next season to gauge Chudzinski’s effectiveness.
His ability to lay out his philosophy and identify the kinds of players
necessary to execute it is absolutely critical to this off-season both
in terms of the kinds of free agents that are pursued and the kinds
of players that will be drafted. Chudzinski indicated that he
believes in a run-first type of offense, which has always made sense
in Cleveland. That may very well signal that Oklahoma running
back Adrian Peterson is at the top of their draft board. For anyone
who watched the success that Reggie Bush had in New Orleans this past
season, drafting someone like Peterson makes incredible sense.
But past being prologue, a defensive tackle will likely be their first
pick.