'Tis the season to be optimistic if you're a Browns fan. Every February, we laud the teams free agent signings. Every year in late April, we praise the Browns draft picks. Only to be disappointed come fall. We are Charlie Brown, thinking this is the time Lucy won't pull the football away. But in his latest, Erik Cassano says this year feels a little different.
No one needs to tell fans of the Cleveland Browns how to hope.
Hope
is that eternally-springing thing that appears every April when the
team makes their draft picks and slowly builds throughout the summer.
Hope is that feeling you get, no matter the team's recent track record,
no matter the wannabe-cynical
defense mechanisms you've erected to save yourself from further
disappointment, that this year will be different, that this draft and
free-agent class will be the desperately-needed cavalry that is going
to turn the tide.
Hope caused Browns fans to believe in Kelly Holcomb as a starting quarterback. In brittle Lee Suggs as a feature running back. In Gerard Warren as the next Warren Sapp.
From the high-profile (Tim Couch, Courtney Brown, William Green) to the sleepers (Charlie Frye, Luke McCown)
to the where-on-Earth-did-they-find-this-guy (Ben Gay), numerous
players have been the the subject of hope these past eight years. None
of them rewarded the hope, at least long-term.
Yet every April it starts again. Kellen Winslow. Braylon
Edwards. The drafts are widely-accepted, never harshly-criticized by
the fans because we want to believe our team is doing the right thing,
finally. But the losing seasons just keep on coming.
You'd be
excused if you wanted to buck the hope trend, cross your arms and go
into full "Prove it" mode the past couple of years. With their track
record, the Browns deserve nothing more.
That's what makes the
events that affected the Browns on Saturday so difficult from an
emotional-investment standpoint. As a fan of a team that has so
consistently failed you since 1995, you'd have every right in the world
to assume that Browns blew their third overall pick on an overrated
offensive tackle in Joe Thomas, then gave up way too much to Dallas to
move back into the first round and select an overrated quarterback in
Brady Quinn.
You'd have every right to have a several-second
flashback to the 1989 Herschel Walker trade, in which the Vikings
essentially started the Cowboys' 1990s dynasty by trading a boatload of
draft picks to Dallas for Walker.
You'd have every right to believe the Dolphins made the correct choice when they passed over Quinn in favor of Ted Ginn Jr. at pick No. 9.
You'd
have every right to believe this is all going to end badly for the
Browns, as things always seem to do. No one could fault you. History is
on your side.
So why does this draft feel different? It goes
beyond the cautious optimism that surrounds every draft to a feeling of
real change. It's undeniable, no matter how hard you try to chalk it up
to hype.
The Earth moved under Cleveland Saturday afternoon, and
it had nothing to do with fault lines. It really wasn't even about
Thomas or Quinn. They were the end products.
Saturday was the
day that Phil Savage stopped behaving like Dwight Clark and Butch Davis
before him. Saturday was the day that a long line of Browns GMs-as-self-proclaimed-master-craftsmen
stopped. Saturday, Savage tossed aside the step-by-step master plan and
started trying to win out of necessity.
Every GM attempting to
rebuild a team seems to have a plan. A three-year plan, a five-year
plan. It helps him look organized. It helps draw confidence from team
ownership. But rarely does the plan follow the script start to finish.
In the Browns' case, it rarely gets past "start" before there are
problems.
Maybe it was the LeCharles Bentley injury a year ago. Maybe it was the rash of staph infections in Berea.
Maybe it was watching Gary Baxter's career likely end before his very
eyes. But somewhere along the line, Savage realized that time is an NFL
GM's greatest opponent.
ESPN analyst Mark May chided the high price the Browns paid to acquire Dallas' 22nd
overall pick and draft Quinn. He said the Browns were gambling with
their future in trading away their first-round pick next year.
True.
But the Browns have had nothing but "future" since re-entering the
league. Sooner or later, that future has to become the present, or the
guys who decide the team's future won't be making the decisions anymore.
Saturday,
Savage made two bold moves in acquiring Thomas and trading for the
right to draft Quinn. Not because he wants to be known as a GM who
makes bold moves, but because bold moves are the only way he is going
to ensure he and head coach Romeo Crennel keep their jobs.
The
Browns have to show rapid, significant improvement starting with the
outset of training camp in late July. Tough schedule be damned,
injuries be damned, staphylococcus aureus be damned. There are no excuses that can cascade from theGM's chair that will take root with a fan base -- and more importantly, an owner -- desperate for wins.
Savage, smart cookie that he is, quickly realized that. Instead of trying to egotistically
re-invent a bigger, better wheel, he's trying to find the best talent
he can at key positions and get a winning team on the field as soon as
possible. Which is a GM's job in the end.
That, by itself, is the reason why there is something beyond hope in Cleveland today.